Skip to main content
For Independent Insurance Agencies

They Ask, You Answer for Insurance Agencies.

Marcus Sheridan's "They Ask, You Answer" is the most proven inbound marketing framework of the last decade. Pool companies used it. HVAC. Manufacturing. Roofing.

And almost no insurance agencies have ever been coached through it properly. That's the gap we fill at Niche Your Business.

The Framework

What Is They Ask, You Answer?

They Ask, You Answer (TAYA) is a business philosophy created by Marcus Sheridan after he saved his pool company from the 2008 housing crash. The idea is brutally simple: whatever your customers are asking, answer it openly and honestly on your website — better than anyone else in your industry.

Sheridan turned a failing pool company into one of the largest pool installers in America by becoming what he called "the Wikipedia of pools" — publishing detailed answers to every question buyers had, including the ones other pool companies refused to talk about (real costs, real problems, honest comparisons to competitors).

The same playbook now drives growth for businesses in dozens of industries. But insurance has been one of the slowest to adopt it — which is exactly why agencies that move first are winning.

Create Customers for Life
The Opportunity

Why Insurance Agencies Are the Perfect TAYA Industry

Insurance buyers have more questions than buyers in almost any other category. They're spending hundreds — sometimes thousands — of dollars per year on a product they barely understand, sold to them by an industry that often treats transparency as a competitive risk.

Every one of those unanswered questions is a search query. Every search query is a buyer.

Most insurance agency websites still look like this: a stock-photo hero, a list of carriers, and a "Get a Quote" button. They don't tell you what coverage costs. They don't tell you what's covered. They don't tell you what's not covered. They certainly don't compare themselves honestly to the agency down the street.

The agency that breaks that pattern wins the market.

The first agency in your niche to actually answer the questions buyers are asking online will dominate that niche for the next decade. Everyone else will be playing catch-up.

Trusted Agent
The Big 5

The TAYA Big 5, Applied to Insurance

The heart of They Ask, You Answer is what Sheridan calls The Big 5 — five content categories that drive the overwhelming majority of buyer decisions. Here's what each looks like when applied to an insurance agency.

1

Cost & Pricing

The number one question every insurance buyer has — and the number one question most agency websites refuse to answer.

  • How much does business insurance cost for a contractor in Georgia?
  • Why did my homeowners premium go up 30% this year?
  • What's the average cost of flood insurance in a non-flood zone?
  • How much should a restaurant pay for liability coverage?
2

Problems

Every product has downsides, gotchas, and edge cases. Talking about them openly is the fastest way to build trust.

  • 5 reasons your homeowners claim might get denied
  • What's not covered by a standard business policy
  • The hidden problems with the cheapest auto insurance
  • Why captive carriers might not be your best option
3

Comparisons & "Versus"

Buyers compare. They will compare with or without you. Better to be the source they compare with.

  • NFIP flood insurance vs. private flood: which is right for you?
  • Captive agent vs. independent agent: pros and cons
  • Term vs. whole life insurance, explained honestly
  • State Farm vs. Allstate vs. independent agency in [city]
4

Reviews

Buyers Google 'review of X' before almost every purchase. If you're not in the conversation, you're not in the consideration set.

  • Honest review: working with [Carrier] for the last 10 years
  • Is [Carrier] really cheaper for new drivers?
  • [Carrier] homeowners insurance: what we've actually seen on claims
  • Review of [competitor agency]: when they're the right call
5

Best-In-Class & "Best Of"

The 'what's the best' question. Position your agency, your niche, or your recommended carriers — honestly.

  • The best flood insurance for properties outside high-risk zones
  • The best umbrella policy for high-net-worth homeowners in Georgia
  • Best independent insurance agencies in [city]
  • The best business insurance for general contractors in 2026
The Video Framework

The Selling 7: TAYA's Video Framework for Insurance

The Big 5 is what you write. The Selling 7 is what you film. Together they form the complete TAYA content engine. These are the seven videos every insurance agency should have on their website:

1

Bio videos

Short intros for every agent and CSR on your team, so prospects can see who they'll be talking to.

2

Cost & pricing videos

Walk through how premiums are actually calculated and what affects them.

3

Product explainers

What each line of coverage actually does — in plain English, not insurance jargon.

4

Landing page videos

Short, specific videos for each service or niche page on your site.

5

Customer journey videos

What happens after you submit a quote, file a claim, or renew.

6

"Claims of fame" videos

Your differentiators, told as stories — not bullet points.

7

Social proof videos

Real client testimonials, ideally on camera, ideally specific.

The Secret Weapon

Assignment Selling: The Part Most Agencies Miss

Here's where most agencies that "try TAYA" fall short: they publish the content, get some traffic, but never actually use the content during the sales process.

Assignment selling is the practice of giving prospects specific content to consume before they get on a call with you. A short article. A specific video. A pricing guide.

For an insurance agent, that means: when a prospect calls or fills out a form, you don't immediately quote. You reply with something like:

"Before we get on a call, I'd love for you to watch these two videos and read this short article. They'll answer your biggest questions about [coverage type] and tell you whether I'm the right fit. Once you've done that, book a 15-minute call here."

The result for agencies that do this consistently:

  • Close rates jump dramatically — prospects arrive educated and pre-sold
  • Sales calls get shorter — you skip the "Insurance 101" portion entirely
  • Bad-fit prospects filter themselves out before wasting your time
  • You position yourself as the expert, not a vendor competing on price

This is the part of the TAYA system that produces immediate revenue lift — usually within 30 to 60 days.

Why Niche Your Business

Why Generic TAYA Coaches Won't Work for an Insurance Agency

You can hire a generic TAYA coach. They'll teach you the framework. They'll review your content. They'll help you build a calendar.

But they won't understand:

  • Why insurance is a regulated industry and certain claims (especially around price) need to be framed carefully
  • How carrier relationships affect what you can and can't say publicly
  • What the actual buyer journey looks like for personal lines vs. commercial vs. specialty
  • How E&O exposure intersects with content marketing
  • Which insurance niches have the cleanest content opportunities — and which are traps

We do. Niche Your Business is built specifically for insurance agencies — and we coached the agent who used this exact system to build a $2.5M flood-insurance business from scratch.

The Engagement

What's Included in Our TAYA Coaching

Every engagement is built for the specific agency, but the core deliverables are the same:

  • Niche identification and a custom Big 5 content map built for your agency
  • Weekly 1-on-1 coaching calls covering content, video, and sales-process integration
  • Selling 7 video coaching — what to film, how to film it, and how to get better on camera
  • Assignment selling playbook — exactly how to integrate content into your quote-to-close workflow
  • Quarterly strategy reviews and content audits
  • Access to insurance-specific content templates and frameworks
  • Email and Slack support between calls
Common Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

What is They Ask, You Answer?

Does They Ask, You Answer actually work for insurance agencies?

What's different about your coaching versus a generic TAYA coach?

How long until They Ask, You Answer produces results for an insurance agency?

Do I have to be on video to do TAYA?

What if my agency is captive (State Farm, Allstate, Farmers)?

How much does TAYA coaching cost?

Final Call To Action

Become the Most Trusted Voice in Your Insurance Niche.

 The agencies that move first on TAYA in their niche will dominate the next decade of insurance buying. Everyone else will be paying paid-ad costs that go up every year. If you want to be one of the first movers in your market, partner with Niche Your Business. The next step is a free 30-minute call.